top of page

Who Pays for Green Growth? Lessons from the UK's Levy Reform for Malaysia's Industrial Transition

2 days ago
6 min read

Prepared by Pavitra Ragunathan

12 November 2026


Countries around the world are on a mission to achieve net zero emissions, but the real question is who bears the cost. Green policies are not just environmental targets, but financial decisions that determine whether the transition is fair or a rushed one.

What Is a Green Levy?

Green levy is a tax imposed by a government on activities or products that contributes to environmental pollution. The revenue generated is then used by the government to invest in green initiatives, incentivising decarbonisation and promoting energy efficiency.

The green levy system in the UK refers to the climate change tax that can be found on the energy bills for households and businesses. Mechanisms such as the Climate Change Levy (CCL), Renewable Obligation and Feed-in Tariffs imposed by the UK government to achieve their net zero emissions by 2050 by promoting renewable subsidies, energy efficiency programmes and low-carbon transition.

The Electricity Bill Dilemma

The UK manufacturers, especially the Confederation of British Industry (CBI) and Energy UK are pushing back against the green levies on electricity bills as it threatens the industry. High energy costs are putting investments in jeopardy, thus operation and industry growth in jeopardy. This burden is borne by the firms and ultimately passed through to the household consumers in the form of everyday prices.

This movement exposes a core dilemma on who should bear the cost of green growth transition, whether the consumers, taxpayers or the industry itself. Electricity prices in the UK have recorded at 45% above the G7 median and have put the firms on the back foot to compete on the global stage. The green levies are designed to support the government’s initiative to fund renewable energy projects but in reality are causing electricity to become more expensive than fossil fuels.

Green Levy Mechanisms in Malaysia

Malaysia’s green levy works similarly to the UK’s. It is called the Renewable Energy Fund Levy (KWTBB) or also known as the Kumpulan Wang Tenaga Boleh Baharu. Malaysia is also preparing for a carbon tax in 2026 which will be imposed on energy, iron and steel industries, and is currently under review. This tax could potentially increase costs for these industries, which is most likely to cascade down to consumers.

Like all countries, Malaysia is also committed to achieving net zero emissions by 2050 and to support this goal, the National Energy Transition Roadmap (NETR) outlines the shift from heavy fossil generation to 70% renewable energy (RE) in installed capacity by 2050 that needs up to RM1.85 trillion. New funding mechanisms such as green levies are imposed to fund these investments.

The KWTBB imposes a 1.6% charge on the net electricity bills of specific consumers. Domestic consumers with monthly consumption exceeding 1,500 kWh, commercial and industrial electricity consumers face these additional charges. The KWTBB funds renewable energy programmes under the Sustainable Energy Development Authority (SEDA). Malaysia is also committed to several reforms that affect energy costs. The fuel subsidy rationalisation for diesel and RON95 petrol towards a targeted mechanism. These subsidies have become a huge fiscal burden to the government.

The Imbalance Cost Pass-Through (ICPT), a slight tariff hike to the industrial sector and the wealthy to fund the public utilities. For the first half of 2025, the government expected to fork out RM2.4 billion in electricity subsidies. However, the ICPT was replaced by the Automatic Fuel Adjustment (AFA) under the Regulatory Period 4 (RP4) tariff framework and is now recalculated monthly by the Energy Commission, could be a surcharge or a rebate depending on global fuel price and exchange rate movements. More businesses will be seeing an increase in their electricity bills depending on their usage.

Though the mechanisms are different, the questions are still the same. Who pays the cost of decarbonising? Should it sit in the consumers’ monthly electricity bill, with industry via tariffs or with the government through rationalised fuel subsidies?

Why Malaysia Has Less Room for Error

Unlike the UK who is a predominantly service-driven economy, Malaysia is an export-driving manufacturing economy and the exports growth contributes to the nation’s GDP. Malaysia cannot approach the trade off the same way as the UK.

Firstly, Malaysia could risk losing its competitive edge in the global market. The manufacturing sector hits the most as the sector is deeply integrated into the global supply chain and the nation’s economy depends on exporting critical products such as electric and electronics (E&E) products, petroleum products and machinery, equipment and parts. Once the carbon tax is finalised, it is going to hit manufacturers hard as they struggle to remain globally viable, and investors shift to competing markets like Vietnam, Thailand and Indonesia. Affordable electricity is crucial for staying competitive, securing a steady flow of investment and maintaining a stable economy. Without careful plans, these rising operational costs could also displace thousands of jobs.

Secondly, Malaysia’s narrow fiscal budget also poses a risk. Unlike the UK, the Malaysian government operates with a narrower fiscal margin, targeting a federal deficit reduction to 3.5% of GDP for 2026 even as the government debt stands at 65.3%. Malaysia typically relies on heavy subsidy reforms rather than implementing wealthy taxes which exceed its budgetary deficits that could trigger inflation if not managed precisely. While the UK has greater economic resilience and could absorb shocks with its high tax collection capacity and the reserve currency. For Malaysia, every ringgit spent on subsidising industrial electricity costs means one ringgit not spent on fuel subsidy or social welfare programmes.

Thirdly, the energy transition faces intense political and socioeconomic friction. In the UK, the green levy system is already implemented, and the debate now is over who should pay for it, while in Malaysia, its financing mechanisms are still politically contested. The proposed carbon tax remains under review, fuel subsidy rationalisation continues to face political and public scrutiny and the uncertainty in electricity bill due to the AFA. If these reforms are pushed without careful consideration of their distributional impacts on households and businesses, they could face strong public resistance, undermine industrial competitiveness and erode public support for the broader energy transition.

Who Should Bear The Cost

If consumers bear the cost, the transition burden lands on their monthly electricity bills, driving up the living costs directly, especially for the B40 and M40 groups. If manufacturers pay for decarbonisation, these transition expenses may be passed on through higher industrial tariffs, increasing operational costs and making products more expensive. This could place financial pressure on firms which could force them to scale back or shut down operations, leading to job losses. As production costs rise, Malaysian made products may also become less competitive against producers in other countries.

If we expect the government to absorb these costs, it raises a different problem. With national debt remaining high and ambitious deficit targets in place, shifting government revenues to fund energy subsidies creates an opportunity cost, leaving less funding for essential public services like schools, healthcare and infrastructure.

It is absolutely impossible to let one group shoulder the cost alone as each option creates a new problem. The real challenge is finding the right balance between them, and Malaysia still has the time to get this right rather than discovering too late.

A stronger strategy would be an integration of dual instruments, combining the carbon tax and emissions trading system (ETS). A study by Pan et al. (2024) evaluated the efficiency of the integration of carbon taxes, ETS and other climate policies that have applied in Scandinavian countries. The study confirmed that integrating both carbon taxes and ETS achieves emission reductions while maintaining economic efficiency, rather than relying on either mechanism alone.

Malaysia could adopt a phased implementation, targeting large scale emitters. Revenue raised could be invested into green technology innovation or channelled into subsidies that help SMEs adopt digital transformation and ESG compliance simultaneously, for instance, shared-services platforms offering SMEs subsidised access to cloud-based ESG reporting tools.

Energy transition financing matters as much as climate targets if Malaysia wants to achieve net zero emissions by 2050. The question is not whether to impose green levies, but how they are structured to ensure costs are shared equitably, economically viable and environmentally effective. Climate and sustainability policies should be paired with financing plans that outline who funds the transition and how.

Reference

  1. Acheampong, A. O., Opoku, E. E. O., & Dogah, K. E. (2023) “The Political Economy of Energy Transition: The Role of Globalisation and Governance in the Adoption of Clean Cooking Fuels and Technologies”

  2. Hoong, L. W. (2025) “Malaysia PM Confirms ‘Slight Increase’ in Electricity Tariffs for Industry Sector”

  3. Ikram, I. (2025) “No Fuel Surcharge, Rebate for Electricity Bills This Month As Automatic Adjustment Mechanism Kicks In”

  4. Pan, J., Cross, J. L., Zou, X., & Zhang, B. (2024). “To Tax or To Trade? A Global Review of Carbon Emissions Reduction Strategies”

  5. Puttkamer, L. and Schwerdtfeger, M. (2025) “What are Green Levies”

  6. TheStar (2026) “UK Industry Urges Overhaul of Green Levies as Energy Costs Bite”

  7. Yunus, A. and Sallehuddin, Q. (2026) “Malaysia Nears 2030 Renewable Energy Target Ahead of Schedule, Says Fadillah”

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page