The Case of Environmental Solutionism in a Burning World
Prepared by Claudia Ng
17 November 2026

Members of the all-women The Power of Mama (TPoM) volunteer firefighting team spray water onto smouldering peatland in West Kalimantan.
This year, the haze has draped over the Malaysian skyline yet again, and so has the same conversation. First came the fit of anger at the neighbour whose fires caused it, then a round of finger-pointing. Not their first rodeo. What followed was always something close to collective resignation; ASEAN’s non-interference norm leaves Malaysia asking but not compelling. The prevailing sentiment was that something as transboundary as haze falls outside any single state’s jurisdiction, leaving no one to claim responsibility. After all, the haze does not travel with a passport, nor is it issued a visa to determine its duration of stay. The argument only caught on fire as long as the haze lingered. Once the sky cleared, it faded from our feeds and news headlines, and we are once again left with the anxiety of anticipating its fateful return next year. Few consequences followed, whether legal, financial, or in how the region manages karhutla (forest and land fires) and, most notably, Malaysia’s purview over the matter.
State v. state
The idea of suing Indonesia has gained traction but has never become a palpable action. In 2019, a Malaysian civil-society proposal, backed by a group of doctors, lawyers, academics, and economists, urged Putrajaya to file a symbolic RM1 suit against the Indonesian government. More recently, Khairy Jamaluddin famously likened the situation to dealing with a “banana republic” due to the Indonesian government’s weak environmental law enforcement and sluggish corporate prosecutions. Other political figures, such as MP Lim Guan Eng and MP Syed Saddiq, have grown increasingly vocal in urging ASEAN and Malaysia to take firmer steps, including the creation of an ASEAN firefighting task force. MP Syed Saddiq has also called for legislation modelled on Singapore’s Transboundary Haze Pollution Act, one that would hold Malaysian companies with a hand in the concessions responsible. Meanwhile, the only lawsuit actually filed is in Indonesia, where a coalition of civil society and indigenous groups in West Kalimantan has launched a class action in Pontianak, naming President Prabowo and other officials over negligence and mismanagement in ongoing wildfires.
Why the inaction?
The first obstacle is the legal vehicle. Malaysia and Indonesia are both parties to the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, but the agreement has no clause referring disputes to the International Court of Justice (ICJ). Moreover, ASEAN has no regional court to turn to, and its operational model relies on intergovernmental cooperation, consensus-based decision-making, and a strict adherence to a non-interference approach, rather than a supranational executive body. While Singapore’s Transboundary Haze Pollution Act of 2014 gives the nation the legal entitlement to fine foreign companies that burn in Indonesia, Malaysia has no equivalent yet.
If we have learned anything from recent discourse, it is that accountability dissolves in layered patronage networks and conflicts of interest. The recurring fires reflect the Indonesian government’s failure to anticipate problems and coordinate a proactive response. Weak oversight of oil palm plantation permits, fragmented coordination between regional and central government, and uncertainty around the Peatland and Mangrove Restoration Agency’s (BRGM) extension at the end of 2024 left the firefighting in disarray.
Moreover, the Job Creation Law stipulates that criminal prosecution of corporations only acts as a last resort if permit revocation and environmental restoration fail. To gather direct proof behind a company’s involvement, investigators must also trace the exact source of the ignition and the coordinates to pin down neglect or intent. Together, these obstacles are the biggest barrier to holding anyone to account.
The sore thumb in the haze debate
Let’s say we do have all the legal tools for a lawsuit. What’s next? Even the best legal route has its limitations, because it would still treat haze as an isolated event with a culprit and a remedy. How it’s framed in both countries reinforces this: Malaysia treats haze as a public health issue, while Indonesia treats it as a natural disaster and enforcement challenge. Both narratives overlook the structural role of transnational corporate agriculture unless its effect on society is made impossible to ignore. Each narrative only invites a technological and managerial fix once disaster has struck, instead of containing the preconditions that start the fire in the first place.
This is where the critique of solutionism comes in. The term comes from Evgeny Morozov’s “technological solutionism”, and applying it to the environment means questioning the habit of a neat, quick, market- and technology-driven fix at any event of environmental disaster. For example, water-bombing and cloud seeding are treated as the default response to suppress wildfires, and both are very costly. The cloud seeding program in Sumatra and Kalimantan has expended Rp2 billion within a week. A newer approach utilises a cloud-seeding material called Dumakron to be dispersed using aerial vehicles rather than traditional manned aircraft. Malaysia, along with other countries, has also been granted official permission to cross into Indonesian airspace to conduct cross-border cloud seeding operations. These tools are useful, but they treat symptoms as disaster management.
Reliance on quick techno-fixes also diverts attention away from corporate accountability. Indigenous communities are often scapegoated, with blame shifted away from commercial land-clearing onto traditional small-holder practices. In fact, these communities have governed their ancestral land for centuries through customary management systems. Their community rules set out when to burn, wind calculation, where to put firebreaks to control the spread of the fire, and restore soil fertility.
Analytical studies have also shown that community-based prevention measures such as water reservoirs and canal blocks are more cost-effective than emergency firefighting. Solutionism often reverses this priority, exhausting both domestic and international resources on disaster management while shifting the blame onto indigenous communities, whose practices are more sustainable and thus must be distinguished from large-scale clearing.
Malaysia’s non-solutionist approach
For the Malaysian government, this means resisting the comfort of a single instrument. A Transboundary Haze Act is now under consideration, and it would be a welcome tool. Unlike a state-to-state lawsuit, a Singapore-style law is aimed at companies, not directly at the Indonesian state, which may spare the countries’ delicate bilateral ties. Yet officials have themselves acknowledged that legal tools must be paired with regional cooperation. Science diplomacy and the proposed Sustainable Haze Fund are good next steps for scientific data procurement and financial assistance, but they only matter if they lead to accountability and not just purely monitoring and damage control. Thus, science diplomacy must look beyond technological fixes, prioritising community-based prevention and respect for indigenous practices. For accountability to be viable, legal tools must be paired with tracking of corporate-linked concessions, supply chains that meet No Deforestation, No Peat, No Exploitation (NDPE) commitments, and attention to agrarian inequality among rural populations. After all, quibbling over blame will not stop the fire, nor will it prevent another one from happening again.



Comments